Imagine being the hero of the hour, scoring a last-minute winner against a fierce rival, yet still feeling like you’re on the sidelines of your own story. That’s the reality for Matheus Cunha, Manchester United’s summer signing, who’s been making waves despite his limited starting role. But here’s where it gets controversial: is his impact off the bench a testament to his versatility, or a sign that he’s being unfairly overlooked? Let’s dive in.
Former Manchester United midfielder Nicky Butt recently shared his thoughts, admitting he ‘feels sorry’ for Cunha after the Brazilian’s dramatic winner against Arsenal in a thrilling 3-2 comeback. The match at the Emirates Stadium was a rollercoaster: United clawed back from a goal down to lead 2-1, only for Mikel Merino to equalize with six minutes remaining. Then, in a moment of brilliance, Cunha—who had come off the bench—dribbled to the edge of the box and unleashed an unstoppable strike past David Raya, securing the victory.
Cunha, signed from Wolves for £62.5 million in the summer, has been a reliable contributor this season, tallying five goals and two assists in 20 Premier League appearances. Yet, his role as a substitute has sparked debate. Both Butt and Paul Scholes believe Cunha is unlikely to be satisfied with his current position, despite Patrick Dorgu’s injury potentially opening the door for him to start against Fulham.
Speaking on The Good, The Bad and The Football podcast, Scholes highlighted Dorgu’s unique impact under interim manager Michael Carrick. Originally brought in as a wing-back to fit Amorim’s system, Dorgu has adapted to a more defensive role, often doubling up with the full-back to neutralize threats like Arsenal’s Bukayo Saka. ‘It’s like having two left-backs at times,’ Scholes noted, praising Dorgu’s work rate and goal-scoring ability. However, he questioned whether Dorgu’s long-term future lies as a left winger, suggesting Carrick sees something special in him—enough to keep Cunha on the bench.
Butt chimed in, acknowledging Cunha’s value as a super-sub: ‘He’s giving you an option off the bench, and I do feel a bit sorry.’ Scholes agreed, adding, ‘He won’t be happy with that, no chance.’
And this is the part most people miss: Cunha’s role isn’t just about scoring goals. As Butt pointed out, he’s a player who can carry the ball, draw fouls, and kill the clock when United are ahead. ‘He could end up being a super sub,’ Butt suggested, though he acknowledged the competition from Mbeumo, who has excelled as a number nine. ‘Cunha might see himself on the bench for a good few weeks now,’ Butt added, raising questions about his long-term role in the squad.
But here’s the controversial part: Is Cunha’s bench role a tactical masterstroke, or is United failing to maximize his potential? Should a £62.5 million signing be content with being a super-sub, or does he deserve a starting spot? And what does this say about the team’s depth and Carrick’s management style?
These are the questions that have fans and pundits divided. What do you think? Is Cunha’s impact off the bench enough, or should United find a way to integrate him into the starting XI? Let us know in the comments—this debate is far from over.
