The Jewish left is facing a complex dilemma as the right gains ground in the fight against antisemitism. Rabbi Charley Baginsky, a prominent figure in Progressive Judaism, shares her concerns about the recent rally in London, where she faced boos and jeers from the crowd. This incident reflects a broader sentiment among liberal and left-wing British Jews who feel isolated as right-wing figures take the lead in condemning antisemitism and defending Israel.
The article delves into the differing perspectives within the Jewish community. Some argue that antisemitism can only be tackled through broad alliances with other minority groups and anti-racist movements. However, others express suspicion towards these spaces, believing that antisemitism has been minimized or tolerated. The research highlights a shift in voting preferences, with support for the Greens surpassing that of Reform among British Jews.
The Jewish Representative Council's Raphi Bloom highlights the historical bond between Labour and Jewish values of social responsibility. However, the Jeremy Corbyn era and attacks on Israel have weakened this connection. Bloom also notes the rise of Reform, which has brought in genuine allies from the Conservative party, but acknowledges the party's past issues with anti-Jewish racism.
Rabbi Baginsky emphasizes the need to address antisemitism within the broader context of tackling all forms of hate. She believes that until society tackles antisemitism, Islamophobia, racism, and misogyny, it cannot be considered safe for any community. However, she acknowledges the challenge of conveying this message when some people resort to isolationist solutions.
The article also explores the concerns of Jewish signatories who called for the exclusion of Nigel Farage from the event due to alleged antisemitism. The appearance of Richard Tice, a Reform UK deputy leader, and his lack of criticism towards a Reform councillor's controversial remarks, further adds to the unease. British Orthodox Jew Andrew Walters warns against aligning too closely with the right, emphasizing the need for skepticism towards parties with despising principles.
The Institute for Jewish Policy Research (JPR) data reveals a decline in support for the two main parties among British Jews, likely due to disillusionment with both Labour and the Conservative party, as well as growing concerns about antisemitism. The Greens have gained more support than Reform, indicating a shift in political preferences.
David Feldman identifies two dynamics of polarization within British Jewish political life: disagreements over Israel and arguments over the drivers of antisemitism. He challenges the notion that antisemitism is solely driven by the pro-Palestine movement, emphasizing the complex interplay of factors.
The New Israel Fund's David Davidi-Brown expresses concern over the tone and rhetoric at the march, while also opposing generalizations that treat the entire anti-racist movement as inherently hostile to Jews. Alan Mendoza's comments about 'alien values' and 'alien religious ideology' further highlight the rising unease within the community.
Rabbi David Mason acknowledges the historical connection between Jewish solidarity with migrants and minority communities but expresses worries about the fraying of this bond. Andrew Walters rejects the idea of a decisive rightward shift, attributing it to fear of the extreme left's potential actions.
The article concludes by acknowledging the difficult path the Jewish community must navigate. Despite the challenges, communal leaders express admiration for the Jewish Leadership Council and the Board of Deputies' efforts to unite different sections of the community. The future of British Jews relies on allyship from wider society, according to Raphi Bloom, emphasizing the need for unity and collaboration.
